Accor ALL Signature Absolute vs XP
A reader asks whether to renew their ALL Signature Absolute subscription or switch to a new XP product, comparing costs and elite status benefits.
A LoyaltyLobby reader faces a decision on renewing their Accor ALL Signature Absolute subscription or switching to a new XP product. Their current plan renewal is due September 3rd, with a potential price increase from 6,720 BRL to 7,788 BRL. For those tracking their overall standings, elite status is key.
According to the source, the reader's core dilemma involves balancing reward points against status progression. The new XP products offer different bundles of points, elite nights, and status points.
Subscription Cost and Value Comparison
The source provides a detailed yearly breakdown of the subscription options and their included benefits.
| Product | Yearly Price | ALL Points Over 12 Months | Elite Qualifying Nights | Status Qualifying Points |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| ALL Signature XP | 1,394 euros | 75,000 | 10 | 2,000 |
| ALL Signature XP Legacy | 1,593 euros | 90,000 | 30 | 7,000 |
| ALL Signature Absolute | 1,297 euros | 75,000 | 30 | 12,000 |
The reader's quoted price for the Absolute plan is 6,720 BRL, which the source states maps to a new price of 7,788 BRL. The source notes that the XP Legacy product would get a member half the way towards Platinum status in terms of nights (30) and status points (7K).
Status Progression Analysis
Elite status is a major factor in the decision. The ALL Signature Absolute subscription provides 12,000 status points annually. A member would then need only an additional 2,000 points to reach Platinum status.
The source calculates the spending required to bridge that gap. It states members earn 2.5 status points per Euro at most Accor brands. Therefore, earning 2,000 more points would require spending roughly 800 euros.
In contrast, the XP Legacy product provides 7,000 status points. This leaves a much larger gap to Platinum. The standard XP product offers only 2,000 status points, making Platinum status significantly harder to achieve.
Reward Points Consideration
The reader noted that switching could mean 1000 more rewards points per month. The table confirms the XP Legacy offers 90,000 total points versus the Absolute plan's 75,000.
However, the source argues this point advantage is outweighed by the status shortfall. It paraphrases the reader's concern, stating the change would make upgrades to Platinum more difficult.
The source's analysis is blunt. It states it does not think that these XP products make any sense, especially if you get the 7,788 BRL price or their next sale price (only for new accounts).
Communication and Pricing Clarity
LoyaltyLobby points out ongoing issues with Accor's communication. The article states ALL Signature's price change is still not clear to members, and the communication from Sao Paulo has not been clear enough. For more detailed company stats and updates, members often seek clarity.
The reader specifically questioned whether their renewal would be at the old 6,720 BRL value. The source does not provide a definitive answer from Accor on this pricing uncertainty.
Based on the comparison, the source concludes the reader should stick with their current plan. It recommends continuing with their existing ALL Signature Absolute plan, as it makes most sense considering the price of the XP options and the lack of status point earnings on them. The analysis prioritizes elite status progression over a marginal increase in reward points.
